Chapters · Water Seven › Water Seven

Chapter 331: The Big Argument

Arc: Water Seven · Saga: Water Seven · Released:

Summary

At Galley-La Company headquarters in Water Seven, mayor/president Iceburg wraps up a meeting; his secretary Kalifa notes that a recurring petitioner, Mr. Corgi, keeps coming to ask for “something” Iceburg has and always leaves in a huff (pp. 2–3). Robin’s wanted poster — now 79,000,000 berries — hangs on the office wall. Aboard the Going Merry, the rest of the crew get the news that the Franky Family failed to recover their stolen money, and that the shipwrights have assessed the Merry. Luffy delivers the chapter’s bombshell: “We owe a lot to Merry Go, but this is as far as she’ll sail. I’ve decided to switch ships.” The shipwrights’ verdict — the Merry’s keel/structure is damaged beyond repair; “she just can’t be fixed,” “can’t be repaired any further,” she won’t even make it to the next island. Usopp erupts: he refuses to abandon the ship that carried them “over every wave, in every battle,” insists he can keep patching her, and rounds on Luffy — “Is that all this ship means to you?!” The argument detonates into a screaming match; Luffy, hardening, tells Usopp “You’re not a ship’s carpenter!” and “I will never turn my back on this ship!” Usopp accuses Luffy of having “gotten all old and made an idiotic decision,” of only pretending to care about Merry while already excited for a new ship, and — gripped by his own inadequacy — pivots: “If you’re gonna abandon this ship… why not do the same with me?! …I’ll just be a burden on you guys… I can’t keep up with the monstrous powers you guys possess!” As Luffy, enraged, is about to say something unforgivable, Sanji kicks him silent (“Cut the crap! You idiot!”). Usopp storms off the ship — “I’M QUITTING THIS CREW.” Outside, he turns back and formally challenges his captain: “Monkey D. Luffy… If I win, I’m taking Merry Go! So fight me for her!! You’re the captain, and this ship belongs to you… FIGHT ME!!” The chapter ends on a DADOOM split-panel of Luffy’s and Usopp’s faces locked in confrontation, the duel accepted.

New reveals

• The Going Merry’s verdict: beyond repair. The Galley-La shipwrights tell the crew the ship “just can’t be fixed” / “…can’t be repaired any further!” — the damage runs to the keel; she “won’t even make it to the next island” and is “about to sink” (pp. 7–9). This is the death sentence the whole arc has been building toward (cross-link Going Merry, Straw Hat Recruitment Pattern).
• Luffy decides to switch ships — “We owe a lot to Merry Go, but this is as far as she’ll sail. I’ve decided to switch ships.” (p. 6). A secondhand replacement runs ~100 million; the crew can’t even afford to repair Merry now that the Franky Family stole their 200 million (pp. 5–6).
• Usopp’s all-out opposition. Usopp refuses to accept the ship can’t be saved, offers to keep patching her himself (“I’ll fix ‘er up like I always have!”), and is told by Luffy “You’re not a ship’s carpenter!” (pp. 9–13).
• Sanji intervenes. As Luffy is about to say something cruel/irreversible, Sanji kicks him mid-sentence — “Cut the crap! You idiot!” / “…or you’ll end up saying things you’ll regret!!” (pp. 14–15).
• Usopp quits the crew. “I’M QUITTING THIS CREW.” / “There’s no sense in traveling together when we have completely different views!” (p. 17). He recasts the loss of the Merry as proof he’s “a burden” who “can’t keep up with the monstrous powers” of the others — “I don’t have any such high ambitions for myself” (re: Pirate King) (p. 16).
• The Usopp–Luffy duel is declared. Usopp formally challenges Luffy: “Monkey D. Luffy… If I win, I’m taking Merry Go! So fight me for her!!” — Luffy accepts on the cliffhanger (pp. 18–19).
• Mr. Corgi named — a recurring petitioner at Galley-La HQ who “comes to [Iceburg] with all kinds of conditions” for “something I have,” always leaving “in a huff” (pp. 2–3). (First on-page naming; the “something” he wants is left a mystery.)
• Robin’s bounty is shown as 79,000,000 berries on a wanted poster on Iceburg’s office wall (p. 3).

Foreshadowing seeds planted

Payoffs (seeds from earlier chapters that resolve here)

Mentions / appearances

• Straw Hats: Luffy (decides to switch ships; accepts the duel), Usopp (quits the crew; challenges Luffy), Nami, Zoro, Sanji (kicks Luffy silent), Chopper (Straw Hat Pirates)
• Galley-La Company: Iceberg (mayor/president, in his office), Kalifa (secretary) (Galley-La Company)
• Named-not-shown / referenced: Nico Robin (wanted poster, 79,000,000, p. 3; she is elsewhere in town), Mr. Corgi (petitioner at HQ, pp. 2–3), the Franky Family (referenced re: the stolen money, p. 5), CP9 (latent, via the Iceburg “something” tell) CP9
• Ship: Going Merry — the subject of the chapter; declared beyond repair
• Location: Water Seven (Galley-La HQ; the canal harbor where the Merry is moored)
• Cover serial: Gedatsu — “Gedatsu’s Unexpected Life on the Blue Sea, Vol. 16: ‘Dig, Dig, Earth Boss‘“

Notable panels

• p. 1 — Title page: “Chapter 331: THE BIG ARGUMENT.” Cover serial: “GEDATSU’S UNEXPECTED LIFE ON THE BLUE SEA, VOL. 16: ‘DIG, DIG, EARTH BOSS’.” Inset art: Gedatsu burrowing head-first down into the earth (mole-mound spray), wearing his Skypiean kasa-style helmet, a tunnel-cloud trail above. (Side B-plot — Gedatsu cover serial.)
• p. 2 — Establishing shots: “WATER SEVEN, THE CITY OF WATER,” “SHIPBUILDING CENTER,” “GALLEY-LA COMPANY HEADQUARTERS.” A meeting wraps (“Well then, that’s all for today. Excuse us.”); Galley-La staff grumble about a “stubborn guy” who “don’t even know if he really has it.”
• p. 3 — Iceburg’s office: Kalifa announces herself (“It’s me, Kalifa”). Iceburg: “Why do they come all the time? Mr. Corgi always leaves in a huff.” Kalifa: “He wants something I have… is it something valuable?” Robin’s wanted poster (79,000,000) is on the wall.
• p. 4 — Cut to the Merry’s deck: “Hey! Usopp is awake!” / Chopper’s relief; Sanji notes “Robin hasn’t returned…” Water Seven’s tiered city visible behind the moored Merry.
• p. 5 — Usopp, bandaged (from the Franky Family beating), apologizes: “I’m so sorry, everyone! Because of me, all that money was…” The crew calms him; “even if we don’t get it back, we’ll still have 100 million” — but “we won’t know if we can” until “this Franky guy comes back.”
• p. 6 — Luffy’s bombshell, big-panel close-up: “We owe a lot to Merry Go, but this is as far as she’ll sail. / I’ve decided to switch ships.” Usopp’s stunned ”?!”
• pp. 7–8 — The verdict lands: ”…THE MERRY GO… …CAN’T BE REPAIRED ANY FURTHER!” / “She just can’t be fixed.” / “…this ship, which is about to sink… the ship we’re on right now!!” Usopp’s wide-eyed horror.
• p. 9 — Usopp: “What’re you saying… Luffy?” Luffy: “At the shipbuilding center, they said she won’t even make it to the next island.” Usopp’s incredulity that strangers (“a bunch of guys you never met before”) convinced Luffy.
• p. 10 — Usopp: “You’re just going to abandon her in a place like this?! And you’re not gonna lift a finger?! …Is that all this ship means to you?!” Zoro: “Usopp, you shouldn’t yell like that!”
• p. 11 — Usopp insists he’ll fix her (“I’ll fix ‘er up like I always have! That’s how we’ve done it so far, right?!”); Luffy, hardening: “You’re not a ship’s carpenter!”
• p. 12 — “I will never turn my back on this ship!” Usopp: the Luffy I know would “have faith in Merry Go’s strength… How can you call yourself the ship’s captain?!”
• p. 13 — Usopp grabs/yanks at Luffy: “I misjudged you, Luffy!” Luffy: “Nothing you say now will change my mind! I’ve made my decision!”
• p. 14 — Usopp accuses Luffy of only pretending to care: “You were just pretending to care about Merry!” Luffy: “Don’t think you’re the only one taking this hard! Everyone on this ship feels the same way!” (THUNK — Luffy grabbed).
• p. 15 — “…you can just take this opportunity to… ” — Sanji’s kick: “FWAK!! / YOU IDIOT!!” stopping Luffy mid-sentence. “Cool down… or you’ll end up saying things you’ll regret!! Luffy, what were you about to say?!” Nami: “AAAH!” Luffy: “No, it’s all right… Oh… sorry, I didn’t mean…”
• p. 16 — Usopp’s self-indictment: “If you’re gonna abandon this ship… why not do the same with me?! …I know I’ll just be a burden on you guys. Like today… I couldn’t even guard the money. Frankly, I can’t keep up with the monstrous powers you guys possess!” / “Luffy, you’re gonna be the Pirate King, right? I don’t have any such high ambitions for myself.” (Flashback silhouette: “Looking back on when I first went out to sea…”)
• p. 17 — Luffy: “We’re a team, aren’t we?! That’s our only connection!” / Zoro: ”…You guys just invited me on the ship.” / WHAM — Usopp turns to leave; a Straw Hat Jolly Roger flag flutters (FLUTTR). Usopp: “I’M QUITTING THIS CREW.” (”?!!” reactions.)
• p. 18 — Usopp walks off (“It’s my own business where I go”); Luffy: “I can’t follow you anymore… Sorry to have been such a burden.” Then the challenge: “Monkey D. Luffy… If I win, I’m taking Merry Go! So fight me for her!! You’re the captain, and this ship belongs to you…”
• p. 19 — “FIGHT ME!!” Wide shot: Usopp braced before the moored Merry; DADOOM!!! split close-up of Luffy’s and Usopp’s faces — the duel is accepted. Cliffhanger.
• p. 20 — SBS “Question Corner”: Oda introduces Buggy’s teacher / Daytime Rider’s friend “Morning Clown” (kanji pun: Morning 朝 → Clown); answers an aspiring artist on whether you can draw with a ballpoint pen (“Sure you can… use whatever supplies you prefer”). Not story content.

Open questions raised

• Who wins the Usopp–Luffy duel, and what does it cost the crew either way? (pp. 18–19.)
• Is Usopp’s departure permanent, or a wound to be healed? How does he come back? (pp. 16–19.) (Seeds the later Sogeking path.)
• What is the “something” Iceburg has that Mr. Corgi — and others — keep coming to demand? (pp. 2–3.)
• What happens to the Going Merry now that she’s been condemned but the crew can’t agree to let her go? (pp. 6–8.)
• Will the crew recover the 200 million from the Franky Family, and does it even matter now that switching ships is decided? (pp. 5–6.)